Sugarfire 55 Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Sugarfire 55, where burger dreams come alive with a barbecue twist! Nestled at 2204 Michigan Ave in Arnold, MO, this casual eatery specializes in juicy pulled pork sandwiches and hearty burgers, perfect for any craving. The menu invites you to indulge in mouthwatering options, from flavorful ribs and brisket to sides like creamy mac and cheese.
What sets Sugarfire 55 apart is its commitment to quality and variety, as seen in unique specials like the South in Ya Mouth, featuring fried cornbread and sweet potato chunks. Customers rave about the generous portions and the option for carry-out or outdoor seating—ideal for a sunny lunch. However, some diners felt that certain dishes, like the mac and cheese, could improve in temperature and seasoning.
Whether you choose delivery or dine-in, Sugarfire 55 promises a delicious experience—a must-visit for barbecue enthusiasts!
Starters
Fried Green Tomatoes
Pork Belly Hush Puppies
Wings
Family Pack
Includes 2 pounds of meat, 2 quarts of sides, a bag of buns, and your choice of BBQ Sauce!
The Imposter
Chopped Turkey, Grilled Onions and Peppers and Cheddar Cheese Sauce on a Toasted Hoagie!!!
Specials
Brisket
Brisket 1 LB Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of brisket by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb.
Brisket 8 Oz Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of brisket by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb.
Brisket 4 Oz Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of brisket by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb.
Brisket Sandwich
Tasty brisket on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
Brisket Plate
Grab a helping of our famous smoked brisket and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with something from our range of sauces for a flavorbalanced meal.
Single Burger 1 Side
This solopattied single is grass fed beef blended daily from our proprietary mix of chuck, brisket and boneless short rib, handpatted and griddle seared, seasoned only in sea salt and fresh cracked pepper then served on a real butter toasted bun. Add lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and house condiments at your request.
Double Burger 1 Side
This doublepattied burger is served with one side. Grass fed beef blended daily from our proprietary mix of chuck, brisket and boneless short rib, handpatted and griddle seared, seasoned only in sea salt and fresh cracked pepper then served on a real butter toasted bun. Add lettuce, tomato, pickles, onions, and house condiments at your request.
Burgers
Cheddar Jalapeno Sausage
Sausage Link Sandwich
Sausage Link
2 Meat Combo Plate
2 sides fountain soda Any 2 smoked meats
3 Meat Combo Plate
2 sides fountain soda Any 3 smoked meats
Meat Daddy
2 sides fountain soda 4 bone rib, jalapeno cheddar sausage link, 4oz each brisket, pulled pork, turkey
Combo Plates
Pork
Pork 1 LB Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of pork by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb.
Pork 8 Oz Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of pork by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb.
Pork 4 Oz Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of pork by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb.
Pork Sandwich
Delicious pulled pork on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
Pork Plate
Grab a 6oz. or 8oz. helping of our famous pulled pork and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavorbalanced meal.
Full Rack Ribs Only
Fullrack 12bone of our famous housesmoked ribs
12 Rack Ribs Only
12rack 6bone of our famous housesmoked ribs
4 Bone Ribs Only
13rack 4bone of our famous housesmoked ribs
Full Rack Rib Plate
Fullrack 12bone of our famous housesmoked ribs and pair it with your favorite side and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavorbalanced meal.
12 Rack Rib Plate
12rack 6bone of our famous housesmoked ribs and pair it with your favorite side and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavorbalanced meal.
4 Bone Rib Plate
Looking for something lighter? Grab a 13rack 4bone of our famous housesmoked ribs and pair it with your favorite side and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavorbalanced meal.
Ribs
Salads
Chef Salad
This meatfull meal in a salad is brought to you by field greens and topped with brisket, turkey, a hard boiled farm egg, tomato, cucumber, cheddar cheese, red onion, lettuce, ranch dressing or cider vinaigrette.
Smoked Turkey Caesar Salad
Our take on this traditional salad is served with romaine lettuce, creamy caesar dressing and topped with a heaping helping of our daily housesmoked turkey, a splash of freshly grated parmesan cheese and housemade croutons.
Salmon Sandwich
We serve smoked salmon in a 5oz. portion on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
Salmon Solo
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of salmon by its lonesome in 5oz portions. This one doesnt come with any sides.
Smoked Salmon Plate
Grab a 5oz. helping of our famous smoked salmon and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavorbalanced meal.
Salmon
Turkey
Turkey 1 LB Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of turkey by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb
Turkey 8 Oz Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of turkey by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb
Turkey 4 Oz Meat Only
Just looking for a light meal, or maybe even a side dish to be added to your breakfast lunch or dinner? We offer servings of turkey by its lonesome in portions of 4oz., 12lb., or 1lb
Turkey Sandwich
Housesmoked turkey on a freshly baked bun. This plate comes with one of your favorite sides. Top with one of our tasty barbecue sauces to round it out.
Turkey Plate
Grab a 6oz. or 8oz. helping of our famous smoked turkey and pair it with your two favorite sides and a crisp fountain soda. Top this with with something from our range of sauces for a flavorbalanced meal.
Big Muddy Side
This bad boy of the brisket sandwich world is served with brisket of course, smoked sausage, horseradish sauce, BBQ sauce, lettuce, pickles. The perfect sandwich for someone who likes a lot of sandwich.
Brisket Cheesesteak Side
This is cheesesteak our style. This Phillyinspired sandwich with an eastcoast attitude is served with brisket with onions, peppers, and cheese on a hoagie roll.
Brisket Dip Side
Carolina Side
Choice of meat, cole slaw, mustard BBQ drizzle
Fried Green Tomato Sandwich
Cole slaw, cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, Carolina mustard sauce on toasted bread.
Specialty Sandwiches
Sides
Baked Beans
Baked Beans 6oz
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Baked Beans Gallon
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Baked Beans Pint
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Baked Beans Quart
This hot, spicy, side is prepared with love daily. Our tangy baked beans are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
BBQ Chips
Hashbrown Casserole
Collard Greens
Cole Slaw 6oz
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased coleslaw is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Cole Slaw Gallon
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased coleslaw is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Cole Slaw Pint
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased coleslaw is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Cole Slaw Quart
This cool cabbage treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased coleslaw is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Cornbread
Deviled Egg Potato Salad
French Fries 6oz
This hot, handcut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
French Fries Gallon
This hot, handcut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
French Fries Pint
This hot, handcut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
French Fries Quart
This hot, handcut potato delight is prepared with love daily. Our french fries are the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
MacNCheese
Fresh Fruit Salad
Potato Salad 6oz
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased potato salad is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Potato Salad Gallon
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased potato salad is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Potato Salad Pint
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased potato salad is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.
Potato Salad Quart
This cool potato treat is prepared with love daily. Our mayobased potato salad is the perfect side to your meatful meal. Served in single servings, by the quart usually for 46 people or by the gallon usually for 1520 people.